And the word for the week is . . .



REVISION!

How could it not be, when I’ve spent most of the past week a) sympathizing with writers struggling with it b) waiting for writers to show me the fruits of it, and c) cudgelling my brains to produce notes that will enable writers to embark upon it.

Yes, Revision is a big, dark, scary word.  It is the Voldemort of writing.  It is the mountain range that stands between the author and an agent.  Between the author and a deal.  Between the author and the nirvana that awaits beyond the magical ‘delivery and acceptance’ clause in their contract - when finally, finally the manuscript passes from being the author’s responsibility and into the hands of the copy-editor, the production department.  Revision - once, twice, three times? Whose counting? - is what comes before the final immense, incredible sigh of relief.

Everyone is frightened of revision, deep down.  Because it means pulling up everything you’ve carefully put together thus far and opening it up once again to the cold and dispassionate light of analysis, rigour and logic.  When any carefully ignored omissions, obfuscations, self-delusions, denials, wobbly bits and messes are forced to meet their nemesis.  Who wants that, when it’s so much easier to keep a few dark corners where the light never shines?  Yes, revision is painful, frustrating and scary, because like a knitted sweater, when you pull out one thread the whole careful ‘knit one, pearl one’ of your beautiful creation can come unravelled in ways you never imagined.  You thought the requisite revision was small, tightly contained, manageable - the sort of hole that might be covered by an orderly little patch, like a puncture in a bicycle tyre. But when you take your gloves off and start getting your hands dirty - changing things, digging deeper - lo and behold, you find not only has the tyre collapsed, but the entire bicycle has folded up and died under you.

This, my friends, is the process and the life to which you have signed up.  It is the way of the professional author, and it is the path of any writer who aspires to be good.  Or great. However tough it is, the more you can open yourself to looking rigorously and honestly at your work and being prepared to rethink, the better the end result is likely to be.  And the less likely you are to be overly ‘precious’ about your writing and creativity. Publishers (and agents) love to deal with authors who will look objectively and exactingly at their work, and who are prepared to be guided in ways to make it even better.

Who do you know who can help you to revise?  Many of you belong to critique groups and that’s a great way to go, enlisting the frank comments and sympathetic support (both being vital) of tried and trusted writer friends whom you respect. But if you don’t know a group like this which you could join, cast about for people you know (probably not family) whose judgement you believe in, and who preferably have some level of knowledge of the market.  People often write to me saying they tried out their story on their children, or on a class at school. Listen to what those children say, but don’t necessarily believe that they will be the best or only arbiters.  All children love to be read to, and the extra dimension of an adult investing time and ‘live performance’ can transform any work of fiction into something superlative.  What you really need, ultimately, are the opinions of those who spend their lives working in the contemporary book scene in whatever capacity - who are used to dissecting plot, who understand the difference between characters that leap off the page and ones that remain two-dimensional, and who are attuned to hearing the cadence of language. If you come upon such a person, make them your best friend!

There are great rewards for those who revise, revise and revise again.  With the right kind of advice and a willingness to learn and rethink, your grasp of your craft will develop and mature, and before too long you’ll be looking back with a hand clapped to your forehead as you yell, ‘That thing I wrote six months ago? How on earth could I ever have written such embarrassing tosh?!’

It’s a bit like my Canon Rebel xti camera.  When I first got this beauteous piece of technology I hardly dared to touch it.  I studied the book for hours, gingerly prodding buttons every now and then.  Six months on I was swaggering around talking about ISO and aperture and shutter speeds (much to everyone’s irritation). I’m still no expert, and I still take some extremely wonky pictures at times, but I’m a million times better than I was.  And if I wanted to be a professional photographer?  Well, I’d do a lot of research and get myself on to the best possible course I could find and pay for, with all speed. Is writing so much different? It is craft. It is art. It is music. It is philosophy and psychology. It is structure, It is all things creative and analytical, all rolled into one form.  It is well worth learning in any way you possibly can - whether from good teachers on simply ‘on the job’.

REVISION. It is a writer’s best friend.  Don’t be afraid of it.  No author ever got there without it.  Be of good courage. 

Posted by on 09/22 at 12:10 AM

Your blog couldn’t have been any more timely!

Today as I slogged through the muck,(I see this revision/re-write as a swamp to traverse instead of a mountain range to scale)I was wondering exactly when I’d find my way out. 

I still don’t have the answer to that, but I’ve strapped on the hip waders - metaphorically speaking because they really are too ugly to wear - and will continue the trek. So, thank you.

Posted by  on  09/22  at  02:55 PM

Very timely! (whispers it)I quite enjoy revision, it’s a bit of a brain teaser to work out what still fits and what has to go. I’ve cut out so many favourite characters and scenes but I know we’ll meet again some sunny day (?)

Posted by Jon M  on  09/22  at  08:23 PM

Besides the fact that it took me a while to figure out what a tyre is, because it is in fact a tire, I found this post nauseatingly on target. Especially the part about the bicycle collapsing, except mine’s an eighteen wheeler and I have to admit I’m getting a little tired of all the work with none of the rewards.

But then I remember who my target audience is and I remember how high the stakes are. If I get even one so called “reluctant reader” to pick up my book, then it better be good. Damn good. I know I have a marketable idea because of all the requests I have under my belt, unfortunately I have also learned that I have a lot to learn. I’ve revised for years but this is the first time I’m letting more than air out of the tires. Who knows, maybe this time I’ll get it right.

Thanks for prodding us along, Sarah. I shall be of good courage!

hilary

Posted by H. Pinski  on  09/24  at  02:09 AM

All generalizations are false wink, and it is not true that everyone is deep-down scared of revision.  Just yesterday, I was reading *The Wand in the Word,* a book of interviews of fantasy writers, and here’s what a couple of them said about revision:

“I love revising, actually.  Composing, although intensely exciting and rewarding, is hard and scary and exhausts both mind and body.  Revising is just gravy.  I have to make myself stop.” Ursula K. LeGuin

“I love revision.  Getting the first draft down is the hard part.  When you are revising, you’re going back,finding which parts really do work.” Jane Yolen.

I’ve also known creative people for whom revision was a procrastination device.  As long as you’re fiddling with it, you don’t have to subject it to the rigors of scrutiny by others, and you never have to start a new work.  You remember the guy Janey Moffat gave her roller skates to fix, who never got to the skates because he was constantly taking the motorcycle apart and putting it back together?  They’re like that.

Personally, I like revision fine, though it can get to be a chore if I have to go over a story too often in a relatively short period of time.  Composition is done in hot mode, the driving eagerness to spill the story out.  Revision is done in cool mode, and is when I get to see the story as a whole and find out what it is.

Posted by Peni Griffin  on  09/24  at  01:37 PM

Thanks Peni and H. Pinski. 
Peni:  You are right that revision has lots of different nuances for different writers. And it is also definitely possible to ‘overwork’ something, endlessly tinkering with it on your own.  It’s good to hear that you and other writers actually enjoy revision! That is such a wonderful outlook and gift to have. Nevertheless, being given pages of revision notes with a deadline (whether from agent or publisher) is, I think, often very stressful for an author.
H.Pinski: ‘Tyre’ is the British spelling. ‘Tire’ is American. See The Oxford Dictionary for Writers and Authors’ smile I have made the decision by and large to stick with my British spelling; just as I’m too old to change my accent. I could be a chameleon and use spellings according to where I am at any time, but feel it’s more natural (and less ‘tiring’!) to stay myself.

Posted by Sarah Davies  on  09/24  at  01:57 PM

Actually, seeing as others are admitting to it - I don’t mind revision either.  Wouldn’t go so far as to say I love it, but to see my story improve is always a good thing.

Although, *gazes wistfully out of window*, I do dream about the day a publishing professional is offering me revision ideas to work on.  Oh well, keep on trying, I guess, and keep on revising.smile

Good luck everyone - I’m going back in to the world of revision and may be gone some time.

Posted by  on  09/24  at  01:58 PM

I’d be terribly disappointed if you became a chameleon! I was actually making fun of myself for how long it took me to figure it out..."Tyre? What’s a tyre?” Duh. 

h

Posted by H. Pinski  on  09/25  at  02:24 AM

I like that time period just after you complete the first draft, that time when you feel like you’ve written something truly wonderful that everyone’s gonna love to read, those few weeks when you allow your burst of creativity to rest, that time before you re-read it yourself and discover you’ve just barely begun your work. That time is paradise.

Posted by  on  09/25  at  01:34 PM

I just began revising my third novel and I’m finding this process gets easier every time. I finished the first draft on Friday and cut several thousand words on Saturday. No remorse, no regret. But the book is already looking a hundred times better.

Posted by Joseph  on  09/28  at  10:33 PM

very awesome blog some how i found you looking for things on our sons birth defect esophageal atresia. I wish you nothing but the best.

Posted by kayla  on  11/03  at  02:41 AM
Page 1 of 1 pages

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL: