Friday, January 21, 2011
All kinds of EXTRAORDINARY

EXTRAORDINARY is a big word today. Everyone wants to be it. Whether that means unicycling while doing the splits on America’s Got Talent, or walking alone around the world, or being the very first person to ride a rhinoceros up the DC Beltway – many of us will do what it takes to be different.
EXTRAORDINARY is a tough call. When I was a bit younger than I am now, we didn’t seem to think about being extraordinary – we just aspired to be GOOD at something. When my mom’s generation was that age they’d settle just for not embarrassing themselves in front of the neighbours. And my grandmother’s generation? Well, the ultimate divide in England was whether or not you cleaned your own front doorstep or had ‘staff’ to do it for you.
EXTRAORDINARY is something I’ve had to think a lot about over the past couple of months as I’ve been preparing my Big Talk for this year – FROM ORDINARY TO EXTRAORDINARY: THE ART OF CREATING A GREAT SALEABLE STORY AND THE CRAFT OF CHISELLING OUT ITS FULL POTENTIAL. What makes a great story? How does it turn from being words on the page into a direct emotional arrow to the heart of the reader? What makes a story an EXPERIENCE rather than just a . . . story?
What I’ll call my EXTRAORDINARY workshop (in content goals rather than presentation!) was trialled last weekend at the SCBWI Florida conference down in Miami. In my first-ever 1.5 hour presentation (look, I never trained as a writing teacher, I’m making this up as I go along and it’s all from experience rather than theory!) I saw what worked and what needed further honing as I took my ‘class’ through ideas of concept, emotion, message, craft tools, tips of the trade, with a small lacing of craziness – like Robert Olen Butler’s suggestion that we write ‘from the white-hot centre of our unconscious’. I love this stuff – the wild, inspirational, raw approach to writing – which then has to meet the subdued skill of craft. Let’s not lose the madness, the wild ride, as we seek those practical ‘silver bullets’ that we hope will shoot open the query process or ‘how to hook an agent’ . . .
I wish I could share all the workshop content with you at this point, but you’re going to have to wait or I’ll have nothing to say at this year’s conferences! If you want to hear more, come to Atlanta (Feb), Seattle (April) or Gettysburg (November). And at the year’s end I’ll try to blog it, as I did with HOW TO WRITE THE BREAKOUT NOVEL, which was last year’s epic. [Look back in my blog posts and you’ll find several sessions on that theme.] And meanwhile, how about pondering how to get your very own WIP to a new level of EXTRAORDINARY?
EXTRAORDINARY is everywhere in the writing world, and nothing is more extraordinary than the generous, committed people who make up the regional leadership and volunteers of SCBWI. Their passion and kindness is truly something to behold. Miami proved my point – from Linda Rodriguez Bernfeld’s stratospheric organizational skills (echoed by her team), Ty Shiver who rescued me from the airport and got me where I needed to be (complete with little bags of home-made cookies and candy), Mindy Alyse Weiss, Michelle Delisle (just for becoming friends) – and so many more. It’s a very moving thing to experience the bonds we share within the writing world.
There are all kinds of EXTRAORDINARY going on in Greenhouse right now, and 2011 has begun with a bang. Julia’s just done an amazing two-book deal with Bloomsbury UK for Sarah Crossan’s debut THE WEIGHT OF WATER. Searingly beautiful though this novel is, I’d have said that getting multiple interest in the UK for aYA verse novel would have been impossible in this climate. Julia’s proved that magic can be done when a great author/book/agent/publisher find each other.
In the US we’ve had all kinds of EXTRAORDINARY too since the year started. THE REPLACEMENT making it into YALSA’s top YA novels of the year, OF ALL THE STUPID THINGS featuring in ALA’s Rainbow list, and picturebook SOAR, ELINOR leaping into the Amelia Bloomer Feminist Book Top 10.
Over in the UK we’ve seen MORTLOCK shortlisted for the prestigious, national Waterstone’s Award and THE BOY WHO FELL DOWN EXIT hitting its THIRTEENTH award shortlist! We are thrilled with all this, but never rest on our laurels – I’m currently in the middle of three deals at the moment, with another offer expected imminently.
EXTRAORDINARY is indeed a big word, but it can feel intimidating and often it’s overused. At Greenhouse we strive for extraordinary, but we would be very, very happy just to be GOOD at what we do. GOOD is achievable. GOOD is solid. GOOD is the foundation of a genuine future.
Is your WIP extraordinary? Maybe not, however hard you work. Maybe the whole idea of EXTRAORDINARY gives you brain-freeze because you know you can never be that person.
But GOOD can be done, and GOOD is what we’re looking for. GOOD is something with which we can work. Aim for the stars of EXTRAORDINARY, knowing that just a little lower resides the more comfortable plateau of GOOD.
As I set off on my next travels, to London this time, I wish you a very, very GOOD day.
Pix: An extraordinary crystal at Reston Craft Fair, VA; extraordinarily meaningful and dramatic old columns at the National Arboretum, Washington DC
Comments (4)
Thank you for this post. It couldn’t have come at a better time. As I am getting ready to finish the first draft of my novel I have managed to allow the excitement that has carried me through to be replaced by sheer panic. This is not my first WIP but it is the first one I have felt such an obligation to my characters and to the story to see it through to the end.I’m not certain if this panic state is because I’m reaching the end of the story, because I know that this is just the first step, as the editing process is just phase two, or if it’s the notion that now that the ground work has been laid it is time to take my story and transform it into something “Extraordinary.” I have often wondered if agents only seek out the fantastic from their many submissions or if they look at the potential a writer may have.
Last night, my husband and I were watching American Idol and he was floored that certain ones made it through. He thought some of the contestants didn’t have any business getting that gold ticket. I think that the judges probably have a completely different mind set when deciding. They are pros in the industry and they may see a little something that the average viewer wouldn’t pick up on. It got me thinking whether or not an agent or editor looks not only for the “WOW” factor but also the diamond in the rough. Someone they can take and shape, and then guiding that writer towards reaching his or her full potential. Then I read your article. (Got it from your twitter post.) You are right. “Extraordinary” is intimidating and it’s use can be crippling to someone’s dream.
“GOOD is achievable. GOOD is solid. GOOD is the foundation of a genuine future.” Your words are encouraging and are just what I needed to squash the panic and replace it with determination and a revived sense of commitment to the story I have to tell.
I was one of your students in the SCBWI class and loved every minute of it. You were informative and gracious, providing us with advice my hand couldn’t write fast enough to capture. I must say I was both shocked and relieved by the claim that you often read the sample work prior to the query letter. Wow! As writers, perfecting the query letter has been hammered into our heads until we can’t see straight. And there you were, at the front of the classroom, driving a giant hole through that advice. I can only hope more agents subscribe to your theory
Thanks again for a great class!
I was lucky enough to test drive your workshop in Miami this month too, and it was truly an EXTRAORDINARY experience. I came home inspired, brimming with ideas, and could hardly wait to get back to my novel. That’s the definition of real teaching and real learning, isn’t it? thanks so much, Sarah.
I’m new to your site and I’ve finished my first children’s novel, but am now in the process of revising & revising, but I love every minute of it; I have since I was a child. I read your website and blog and I just wanted you to know that you’ve given “life” to the word “agent” and I thank you. It was a breath of fresh air.
~d
